Political Assessment

The past few days have seen a frenzy of developments in the presidential race. Democrats Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama continue an amazingly close race which will no doubt keep the suspense going and creates some interesting challenges for the Democratic Party, which prides itself on its identity politics.

John McCain has emerged as a clear leader in the Republican race with Mike Huckabee emerging as the strongest alternative. McCain's lead has caused some restlesness among some conservative media and intellectual leaders, given the Arizona senator's record of positions on various issues ranging from traditional conservative to moderate and sometimes liberal, and his sometimes cantankerous way of expressing those positions. Other conservative leaders point out, even with their disagreements with him, that McCain is a far superior alternative to either of the Democratic contenders. (Not surprisingly, some media reports are sensationalizing this controversy.)

I see a period of 'courtship' where McCain is trying to win over enough conservative supporters to support his campaign and provide a margin of victory in November. There will have to be some give and take, with McCain explaining where he has a largely conservative record, explaining honestly where he differs, and showing respect for those who differ with him (as he did at CPAC last week). Assuming McCain is the nominee, it's also up to conservatives to join in the give and take and consider where they share common ground with him.

It is appropriate for Republican voters in the remaining primary and caucus states who not totally satisfied with John McCain to vote for Huckabee or another alternative. For one thing, the race isn't over yet, and this year has certainly had its surprises. Also, it does give a voice to those concerns that John McCain will have to address assuming he is the nominee.

I see the stakes as too high to sit out the election or even vote for the Democrat as a way of protesting Senator McCain's shortcomings. Perfect can be the enemy of the good, especially taking into consideration the likely agendas of a Clinton or Obama administration. Allowing a defeat this year and expecting or hoping for a comeback in 2012 is not acceptable, given the national security situation and the likelyhood of one or more Supreme Court vacancies in the next four years.

One of the most compelling statements I've read about this situation is this article on ProLife Blogs, focusing on the primacy of protecting human life. (I'm not sure if the aricle is correct in including Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity among those vowing never to vote for McCain.)

So, c'mon, Ann and Rush and Sean and Dr. Dobson. Let's feel free to criticize John McCain for his blunders (and, yes, they are many) and let's do what we can to require him to fill his cabinet with more consistent conservatives. But, goodness gracious, let's not help win the Oval Office, the State Department and the all-important Supreme Court for those who will not only deny all restrictions and regulations of abortion here at home but will promote it as "health services and population control" around the world.